r/AITA_Relationships • u/ThrowRA-guiltyfeelin • 13h ago
AITA for being in a relationship with a married woman, when I thought she was widowed and not married?
The title sounds bad, I feel incredibly bad, but the offended person claims it’s not my fault, so yeah…I’ll try to tell y’all what happened.
I (32m) live in a house in a small town. Two years ago, my neighbour (42f), let’s call her Becca, moves in. Now I am a guy, who loves a good joke and so I have an incredible first impression of her, when she introduces herself to me with a prank. Not gonna tell, what the prank was, she’s using Reddit and I don’t want her to recognise me. So we hang out for the rest of the day till night, we chat, play a card game and chat and joke some more. Next day I visit her, same program and it’s great making friends. We come to know each other and I learn, that she’s widowed (uh-huh), she loved her husband and he died in the first year of their marriage (riiight). So it didn’t really feel wrong, when she asked me out one day and I accepted. Long story short: We got in a relationship together and it was awesome. It was a big plus, that we lived next to each other, but at some point, she had to leave every other week, since apparently her job demanded that. Still: We made it work and at some point we were looking back on two years together.
Then, one evening on a Saturday in a week, when she was away, my doorbell rings. Thinking it’s her, I run to the door and say “Hey there Becs.” I look up and it ain’t her. In front of me stands a tall, muscular, bearded man, very handsome and in his 50s and when I say that, his face becomes this incredibly pained expression. Fk me, I’m about to cry, when I think about this face. He looked so genuinely heartbroken and then he said: Uhm…yeah hi OP…I’m Becca’s husband.”
Now I feel like my heart and balls are falling into a pit beneath me and I notice, just how tall and strong he is, but then, when I see the look on his face, I know he won’t hurt me and I feel so incredibly sad for him. So instead I step back and invite him in.
I lead him to my living room and ask him, if he wants something to drink. He says no, but I tell him “You know, when I was hurt or wronged like that, my gramps would make me hot chocolate with chili, so I’ll make you that. It’s the least I can do.” He smiles a bit at that and even though a few tears roll down his cheeks, this smile makes me feel a bit warmer. So I make him his hot chocolate and then sit down with him. First nobody says anything, but he takes a sip of his chocolate and I think he seems to like it. So I tell him: “Sir, I’m so incredibly sorry.”
He interrupts me and tells me “No Sirs here, please. Just call me John.” I introduce myself to him, before I remember, he already knows that and I could kick myself. I tell him, that Becca told me, she was widowed and I genuinely thought, she was single. If I had known, that she was married or taken, I would have never even gone on a date with her. He listens and nods. He tells me: “Yeah, that’s what I thought. You seem like a good and thoughtful young man. That’s tasty by the way. Thanks for that.”
He tells me, raising his cup, but his smile is so sad, when he says that. He then tells me about his relationship with Becca. How they met and married and how she seemed to have gotten a bit “mysterious” as he puts it, the last few years. He’s 11 years older than her and there was first some frowning about the age gap from friends and family, but they were truly happy together. Or so he thought.
He then asked me, how I met Becca and our relationship and so I told him. He listened, asked questions but he never got angry with me. In fact there were some instances, when we were laughing a bit together, like in a fond way. We then talked about other stuff as well, I told him something about myself and he in turn told me about himself. And guys, let me tell y'all: That man is a fkn saint. He's so smart, has such a big and kind heart, has this sense of humor, that's dumb and sophisticated at the same time. He has done so much good, but he waves it off and is humble, when I tell him, how admirable that is. And then at some point, I look at him, realize what an amazing human being he is and how I hurt him and I just start crying. He's completely surprised by that and asks me, what's wrong and first, I can't get a word out. He then comes over and sits next to me on the couch and rubs my back, still asking "Hey kid, what's wrong? Tell me?" And I just can't stand myself anymore and tell him, how fkn sorry I am, that he's such an amazing and kind person and I'm so sorry, that I hurt him so much. He then starts tearing up himself and I don't know why, because I only know him for a few hours, but I go in and just hug him. He hugs me back and I just cry against his chest, telling him how sorry I am and that he deserves so much goodness and instead I hurt him and cries as well and rubs my back and tells me: "Shhh, it's all right. I don't blame you. You didn't know. And you're a good person. You wouldn never have done that, if you had known, I am certain of it." And yeah, we're kinda sitting there, hugging and comforting eachother. After that, he takes his phone out and searches for limmericks, since that helped him to cheer him up and I do the same and we read a few limericks at each other, laughing our asses off at some point. He then says, that he has to go back home, since Becca was returning from visiting her parents and I accompany him to the door. We hug again and I apologize again and he assures me again, that it wasn't my fault and that he doesn't blame me and so he goes and drives back home.
It's already almost morning again, and even though I feel exhausted, I just know I can't sleep, so I call one of my closest friends and tell him what just happened. He heard how upset I was and invited me to stay at his place. He also told me, that it wasn't my fault and Becca can go fk herself, but I still blame myself also.
He suggested, I use his laptop, make a Throwaway and ask an objective crowd with no ties to me, so here we are.
So I wanted to ask you: AITA?