r/EthicalNonMonogamy • u/Reasonable_Dark8442 • 12h ago
Advice needed what do you do when a partner is catching feelings you can't match?
I (46m) have been seeing someone (35f) regularly—roughly once a week, give or take—for about five months now. I'm married, which she has known since before our first date; she is recently divorced from a long marriage. (My marriage has been open for a almost a year and a half, after almost twenty years of monogamy; this is her first experience with non-monogamy.) We matched on Feeld shortly after she created her account, so I ended up being her first date in about a decade. We like each other, we treat each other kindly and with affection, we're sexually compatible. It's felt like a good and healthy relationship within the boundaries of ethical non-monogamy. We are both still dating other people occasionally.
About two months ago, we had a brief check-in conversation where she told me that while I'm special to her, she didn't want to be my girlfriend, which was a big relief for me—she is special to me too, but I don't want a girlfriend, or to be someone's boyfriend. That might just be semantic, but given how long I was in monogamous relationships versus non-monogamous ones, "boyfriend" carries a connotation that feels more intense than what I want, in terms of time, commitment, and feelings.
But there are patterns we've gotten into that make me nervous. She's also said things like that she's falling for me, or that if I weren't married, she'd be trying to lock me down. I like her a lot, but I'm not falling for her. I am worried about that mismatch, and that I will be letting her down or hurting her feelings if I am not available for a week or two—she has a history (that she came by honestly) of feeling let down by people she's close with, and I don't want to add to that.
We had another conversation a couple of weeks ago where I said that I am still not interested in being a boyfriend or having a girlfriend, that I care about her and value our connection and also hope that she is pursuing other relationships, and that I want her to tell me if it ever goes from feeling fun and good to something that makes her feel bad. She got a little tearful in the conversation, she said because she was worried about losing me.
Since that conversation, things have felt a little better—we looked at her Feeld matches together, and have talked about her meeting my wife, to make that part of my life more real for her—but she also said the "lock me down" thing a few days ago, and I don't ever really know what to say to something like that.
This is the longest and closest relationship I've had since my marriage opened up, and I've never had to navigate this before. Mostly, I'm worried that because she likes the time and attention and affection that I am able to give her, she is putting herself in a position where she will be hurt because she's not getting as much of those things as she actually wants. I've enjoyed stuff like going on dates with her, being affectionate in public, and so forth, but now I'm worried that those things are sending a mixed signal, no matter what I say in other conversations.
TLDR; I'm dating someone I care about but who I'm worried craves a relationship escalator that I am not interested in being on. I don't want to end the relationship, but I'm worried that she might not tell me if it is becoming painful for her in order to keep the relationship going, and I don't want that either.