Never thought I’d agree with a Republican but I have to say I do agree with him on this one:
Today, as students head back to school, New Jersey's "bell-to-bell" cell phone ban officially takes effect. I was one of the only legislators to vote against it, and I want to explain why.
Every generation panics about new technology. When calculators arrived, educators warned that students would never learn math, "what happens when the battery dies?" When the VCR came out, Hollywood claimed it would destroy the movie industry. It saved it. People said the same about streaming, the internet, and laptops in classrooms. Every single time, the panic looked ridiculous in hindsight, and the technology became a tool.
New Jersey has run this exact play before. In 1989, we made it a criminal offense for a student to carry a beeper on school grounds. That law is STILL on the books today. Nobody repealed it because that's what happens with panic-driven laws. They don't age well; they just sit there as monuments to overreaction. Yesterday it was beepers. Today it's phones. History doesn't repeat itself, but in Trenton it sure does rhyme.
The smartphone is the most powerful learning tool ever put in a student's pocket; a calculator, encyclopedia, translator, and research library all in one. The answer isn't a statewide ban. It's teaching kids to use technology responsibly, and letting teachers and local districts decide what works in their classrooms. Discipline problems are a management issue, not a reason for Trenton to legislate every backpack in the state.
Good people in both parties supported this bill with good intentions. But good intentions are how we got a beeper ban that outlived the beeper. Mark my words: schools will eventually embrace phones as a tool, this law will quietly gather dust, and we'll wonder what all the panic was about.