r/calvinandhobbes • u/DBSeamZ • 5h ago
Remember that “would a fairy or a walrus be more surprising to find at your door” debate? The strip where Calvin takes a picture of Hobbes mid-pounce is like that.
A couple of years ago, a post asking “You hear an unexpected knock at your door and look outside. Which would you be more surprised to see, a fairy or a walrus?” went viral. The debates eventually settled into “we know walruses exist, but it would be next to impossible for one to find its way to a residential door—especially without people finding out about it before it got there. We have no evidence fairies exist and plenty of evidence indicating they probably don’t, but *if they did* it would be very easy for one to approach your door undetected.” In other words, the “magic is real” option is a lot easier than the option we know *could* happen.
It’s the same for Calvin’s photo of Hobbes pouncing on him. Calvin’s dad thinks Calvin tossed Hobbes in the air to take the picture, which is *possible.* But Calvin would have needed to throw the stuffed tiger at just the right angle (headfirst, right side up, pointed out the door) *and* take the picture from outside, without his hand being visible in the photo. And without Hobbes landing or hitting the camera before Calvin could push the button. And if it’s a film camera, he would have to do all that *on the first try*, or else physically get rid of the failed attempt photos and hope his dad doesn’t notice the missing film. Again—all that is possible, but really difficult.
If Hobbes is truly animate and pouncing on Calvin under his own power, the explanation for how Calvin took that photo is a *whole* lot simpler.