r/dating_advice • u/Excellent_Detail5196 • 13h ago
My friend and her fiance have an insane agreement on finances. Is this normal?
I figured I would ask here. I recognize that dating is different everywhere in the world, and what might seem normal to some, is a cultural clash with what I may believe, so it may be that I am just weird about this.
My friend is 30F and her fiance is 38M. They're both German, and live near Munich. They got engaged last year, and the wedding is planned for next year. My friend works as a teacher and has a small business on the side. She makes maybe 70k€ or so annually. Her fiance on the other hand has inherited a huge amount of money, and works at his dad's business that has a turnover of tens if not hundreds of millions. So yes, there is a financial gap between the two.
I've never been in a relationship with that big of a gap in finances, but in my experience, when I've dated someone who has made significantly less, I have been happy to pay for the dates. Similarly, when I was a full-time student, and my ex was working, he was paying most of the rent. I think it's fair to expect both people to contribute something (whether it's financially or otherwise), but this situation with my friend is way different.
Recently, her car has been malfunctioning and now she's commuting via the bus for work, 1.5 hours each way. Her fiance has 4 cars, but those are "his" so she cannot even borrow one. They're all fancy Porsches, Mercedes, etc, and hers was a beat up old Kia she has had since early uni.
They live together in a house that is paid off by him and his family, but she is expected to pay him 1200€ rent monthly. For...? Living there.
Whenever he dines out with his friends, he pays for them, but for her, he will pay for groceries and things, but never take her out on fancy dates that he can very comfortably afford. Same with holidays. He will go on her dream holidays with his family, and she can't go because she reasonably cannot afford to drop 30k€ on a holiday. So she stays home.
She doesn't really get material things for birthdays. Only a card from him, maybe some baked goods, chocolates, etc. For Christmas, he mostly has bought her things that she can use around the house (that are not hers). She's into the gym, so he got her a treadmill. He has gotten her kitchen appliances, had the bathroom renovated in a color she preferred, but nothing that she can essentially take out of the house that's really hers. All while he'll buy himself a Rolex or a huge gaming set for Christmas or his own birthday.
For the record also; my friend doesn't like luxury purchases, loves vintage stuff, and doesn't want super expensive things. But she loves things like books, different minerals and stones, etc. She'd be perfectly happy with things like that. From what I reckon,she spends more money on him than he does on her.
Recently, he has been setting up his own side project, an online shop. She has helped with packaging the orders, and in compensation, she hasn't gotten equity, but he has paid her 7€ per hour for packaging the stuff, reducing it from her monthly rent.
I honestly am concerned. Whenever my friend brings this up, she'll say she loves him, and understands, but at the same time, I can see how it affects her. Especially because I am sure she'd do anything for him.
So my question is – how normal is this really? Do some people, even with a huge financial gap, split finances like this? To me it seems insane. If I had a fiance who would have to commute insane hours and I would have several cars, of course I'd let them use one of mine. I don't know. Perhaps it's a cultural difference somehow. Enlighten me.
Edit: A lot of the people are calling my friend a golddigger. She's a lot of weird things, but that's surely not one of them. All of her previous partners were regular people, not wealthy. Fellow students and whatnot. She is also an extremely generous person, even with her fiance although tbh he doesn't deserve it based on how he's treating her. I would say, in my opinion, she's too generous. She has previously helped many other people financially, even when that has itself forced her to skip meals and whatnot.
I forgot to say in my initial post, and perhaps this offers some context as to why she's putting up with this. She has never had a family. She was abandoned at a young age, was in and out of foster homes. She never had behavioral issues in terms of breaking the law, but she has always been gullible. Also, she's the most optimistic person I know, scarily so sometimes; she sort of thinks that everyone is a good person, even when they're not.
She's neurodivergent too, specifically, autistic. She lacks the understanding of social cues, although she is very smart in other ways; for example, she was doing math olympiads all throughout university, and always quickly understands puzzles and any math-y problems. But she struggles with social interaction, and has told me before she cannot decipher people's intentions even when she tries.
She doesn't talk about it a lot, but there's also a dark part of her past. When she was a teenager, she was human trafficked. She has been in therapy about it as far as I know, but she still to this day, tends to think that it would've not happened had she made different choices (ie blaming herself). She sort of has this things that whenever bad stuff happens to her, in her eyes, it's because of something that she did. It saddens me to see sometimes how little she thinks of herself.
So yeah, being with this guy isn't about money for her. She truly loves him, and whenever I ask why, she goes on and on about how he helped her to get out of a dark place when they met, and how he motivated her to continue her studies, etc. She thinks he's the best thing in the world, but I can't help but see how she looks sad sometimes when it's brought up how he treats her financially, especially given how much she has helped him grow his business projects, packaging, building websites for him, doing data analytics for him. She also takes care of the house, cleaning, their dog, everything.