Planning a trip for next late August into early September and deciding between Boardwalk and Old Key West.
Group Details -
Me (30F), Husband (31M), our 2 littles (Daughter turning 3 on trip) and Son (18months) and the grandparents, MIL (56), FIL (55) and my mother (51). Need a minmum of 2 bedroom villa, but would love a 3 bedroom. Celebrating our daughters birthday and my inlaws first ever trip to WDW. My mom has been once 13 years ago and my husband and i have been a few times, always staying at POP. We’ll be bringing our double stroller, flying and not planning on renting a vehicle. Staying on property entire trip. Planning on 5 park days with rest mixed into them and park hopper + disney dining plan. Biggest plans for trip are going to be the family/little kid things, taking our time, enjoying our dining plan and spending time together. My in laws love a relaxing trip and bougier experience (although I’ve prepped them for the WDW trip demands lol), my mom has a tight income but willing to pay the approx $450 per person price difference depending on what the group thinks is best.
Boardwalk
Things we love: close proximity to parks (not having to collapse stroller), central location to other resorts to experience other resorts and the appeal of being able to get to and from the hotel quickly from HS & Epcot.
Things we dislike: price for a 3 bedroom is wayyy out of our budget (almost 3x the price of a 2 bedroom), sharing bus stops with other resorts, smaller villas (my mom would have to sleep on the murphy bed in the common area or share a bed with my son and my daughter sleep on the drop down twin bed in the deluxe studio)
Old Key West
Things we love: 3 bedroom villa (ample space for everyone + 4 bathrooms!), more vacationy feel with disney tied in, boat to disney springs is cool too, but id take a boat or closer distance to a park instead
Things we dislike: isolated feel, bus option to all the parks (collapsing stroller), huge resort with multiple bus stops
Any advice, input or experience is welcome. Any questions about our trip plan/group needs to help us figure out whats best, I’m happy to answer. Or if I’m missing a completely different resort, let me know!