Hello Everyone,
About 9 days ago, I posted four AI mockups of my unfinished living room, each with a different rug. Before making that post, I had already ordered the fourth rug in the carousel (the Nourison), although I had been going back and forth between that one and the first rug (the Nappa). A lot of people here preferred the Nappa.
The Nourison has now arrived, and I actually really like it in person. It has a subtle taupe/beige pattern that I think works well with the room, especially once my dark walnut coffee table, artwork, lighting, etc. are added.
The one thing making me second-guess it is the thickness. My brother walked in and immediately said it was way too thin and looked like a “Temu rug.” I’m not working with a $2,000-wool-rug budget, so obviously there are going to be compromises, but his comment did make me question whether the thinness makes it look noticeably cheaper.
I could add a good rug pad underneath the Nourison, which should give it more cushioning and substance while keeping the low-profile look I like.
So, purely aesthetically, which would you choose for this room: the Nourison or the Nappa? Does the Nourison actually look cheap because it’s thin, or is that not really an issue visually? And if you prefer the Nappa because it looks more substantial, would adding a rug pad under the Nourison change your opinion?
Below is a real photo of my living room with the Nourison, followed by an AI mockup of the same room with the Nappa. Obviously take the Nappa comparison with a slight grain of salt since it’s AI-generated.