This sub convinced me to drive four hours to Virginia Beach to finally see Pennywise live.
I’d mentioned never seeing them before, and the response was basically unanimous: if you love Pennywise, you need to see them live. So my wife and I made a whole thing out of it - four-hour drive, Airbnb, weekend at the beach, all because I’ve loved this band for 30+ years and figured it was finally time.
We left about 45 minutes into their set. I’m still bummed about it.
For context, some of my favorite bands to see live are Descendents, Lagwagon, The Menzingers, Alkaline Trio, Face to Face, MakeWar, etc. I also grew up mostly listening to hardcore and playing in hardcore bands, so loud, aggressive, chaotic - even a degree of "macho" - shows have been part of my life since my early teens.
There was just something about Pennywise live that felt weirdly macho - cheesy, even - and performative to me. I can’t completely put my finger on it, but my wife independently felt exactly the same way. Neither of us was enjoying it. It felt like a pep rally.
What really spoiled it for us, though, was Fletcher going off about how “the right is wrong, the left is wrong” and how everyone just needs to “come together.” He even went off on someone in the crowd who clearly disagreed.
Sorry, bro, but in 2026 that isn’t punk rock to me. That’s just both-sides kumbaya bullshit. You don’t have to agree with everything on the left, but pretending what’s happening politically right now is just two equally bad sides that need to hug it out is stupid. That's not some enlightened anti-establishment position - it’s actually enabling fascism by treating it like just another political disagreement.
And hearing that kind of message preached from the stage by a punk band I’ve loved for three decades was just profoundly disappointing.
I’m not saying Pennywise sucks. I still love the records and always will. I’m honestly just bummed that after finally seeing them, their live vibe apparently isn’t my scene at all - and even more disappointed that part of the show was spent preaching a nonsense “can’t we all just get along” message at a moment when taking a side actually matters.
Curious if anyone else loves Pennywise on record but just didn’t connect with them live...
UPDATE: a lot of comments about how this has always been true, but, in my best Adam Sandler voice, THINGS THAT COULD HAVE BEEN BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION DAYS AGO!