Hi all,
I’m trying to decide between two MINI Clubmans:
2019 Cooper 1.5 petrol – green, 33k miles, 2 owners, automatic
2022 Cooper S 2.0 petrol – red, 47k miles, 1 owner, automatic
I’ll mainly be using the car for city driving in the UK (Birmingham) and probably around 5k miles a year.
For anyone who has owned or driven both, how big is the real-world difference in fuel consumption, especially around town? Is the Cooper S noticeably more expensive on petrol?
I’d also be interested in the difference in insurance, servicing, maintenance and general running costs.
The 1.5 seems like the sensible choice because of the lower mileage and better economy, but I also want something that’s fun to drive. Is the Cooper S worth the extra running costs, or is the 1.5 still enjoyable enough that I wouldn’t really miss the extra performance?
The Cooper S is also 3 years newer and has only had one owner, although it has 14k more miles.
Which one would you choose for mostly city driving?