my actual dinner at the Rockies game yesterday, eaten standing over a trash can
My wife (37F) and I (43M) have a what I think to be a happy, very open, communicative marriage. A year or so ago, we were chatting about her sexuality and how she’s always felt a little gay or bi but never explored it. So I said to her, “Well, you should explore it! I’m sure there is a place on the internet with people in your same stage in life, scenario who are probably having the same thoughts.” And who am I to suppress this? She’s her own woman, we have children, a home and a whole ass life together. Do you really think she’s just gonna throw it all away? And if she is, and she falls in love or something than maybe that’s the way it was supposed to be. I dunno. It felt loving, supportive. And its honestly, how I felt and still feel. It’s nice feeling confident in where you stand with your partner even during hard conversations like this. Anyway, we found Feeld. She made a profile and instantly got a gajillion matches. She’s kind of a sapphic wet dream. Punk-y, stylish, beautiful, effortless. She went on a few dates and it was kind of fun – her coming back from dates telling me about “how weird lesbians are” or “we made out but she had the nastiest apartment.” It was nice seeing her light up, feeling sexy, feeling alive, feeling like a piece of her that was always missing was finally here. And then one day she said, “why don’t we go on these dates together? Would it be weird?” “Umm, fuck no. it wouldn’t be.” “But I don’t want to trounce on your thing, your discovery” “No, not at all this is what I want.”
Fast forward a month, and we are just casually dating not one but two gals. Throuples! One was an elementary school teacher (37F) who was/is one of the funniest people around, and the other was an absolute rocket (26F) midnight ballerina/park ranger (lol shout out Colorado) with a sweet gentle soul. Recipe for disaster, right? Well, kinda.
It lasted for the whole summer and the teacher was also dating someone else at the time and it ended up getting serious and they now live together. But the park ranger, her and I really hit it off and would chat a lot, and to the point where my wife said “if you guys wanted to hang out just you and her, I am open to that, since you let me explore” and of course I said “Let’s do it.”
So there was some overlap here, this developed the same time we had a weekend getaway with the teacher and we were all talking about it and she pulled me to the side and said “I know she said shes ok with it, but don’t. Trust me.”
Well, I did. The next week, We spent the day together, just her and I. We hung out at her place, laughed and connected. We were intimate a bunch and honestly it was great. I genuinely had feelings for her and in another life we may have ended up together. I still think about her. But…did I leave feeling like it was some unrequited love? No. Would she have ever held a candle to my wife? No. Should I have taken the advice of the “teacher”? Probably.
Because later that week, we were all supposed to hang out. My wife, the park ranger and I – and we did. Things got hot and heavy and my wife noticed a bit too much chemistry between the park ranger and I and it was making her uncomfortable I could tell. So afterwards what do we decide to do – go to a sex club. Also, awesome but bad idea. I could tell the vibes were off and I had no idea how to get them back. So I tried to f*ck the awkwardness away, it was hot as hell but still weird. We hung out for a little longer and then went home, and I asked my wife if she could sleep over and she responded with “fuck no, get this bitch out of my house. ” “Will do, babe.”
And that’s the last I saw of the park ranger.
And that’s the last time my wife felt like “exploring.”
I did the thing I didn't want to do. "I don't want to trounce on your thing..."
I let my ego get in the way.
We're happy, still married, just monogamous.
I told her, with complete honesty "You can bang another dude to even up the score, just send me 3-7 pics"
She said "Thats not what it about you stupid fruit"
Anyway, I've never told anyone that story. Sorry if its weird.
TL;DR: Encouraged my wife to explore her bisexuality, we briefly became poly, I got too into one of our girlfriends, ignored a very accurate warning, and accidentally killed the whole experiment. Still happily married. Now monogamous. Learned some shit.
UPDATE: Just in case, y'all were curious. This was Summer '24 (I said a year or so ago) and we are still married. tbh it was a fun season that we had and it had kind of a silly ending, it really wasn't too serious. If anything it was fun, scandalous, playful thing I did with my wife and we learned a lot about communication, being honest and how thinking with your dingus can mess stuff up.