I’m a bi woman and I’ve been with my boyfriend for nearly 5 years. He’s straight and lately I keep thinking I’d probably be happier with a bisexual guy, but I can’t work out if that’s actually about bisexuality or if I’m just becoming unhappy in my relationship.
Before I met him I was 100% planning to date women. I’ve had to remind him a few times that I’m bisexual and that if I hadn’t met him I probably would have had a girlfriend. He can also be a bit low key homophobic sometimes which obviously doesn’t help.
I think one of the things I’m struggling with is that some of his really stereotypically straight man behaviour gives me the ick. He can be very masculine in a way that feels performative sometimes, gets insanely emotional over football, etc, and I just find myself wishing I was with a guy who was more comfortable with femininity and queerness.
We also haven’t had sex in a really long time, mostly because I just don’t feel very sexually attracted to him at the moment. I think when he says things that upset me they stay with me way longer than he realises. He seems to think if we argue and then make up, everything just goes back to normal, whereas for me I’ll still be thinking about something he said months later.
Like he’s made comments about my weight before and I still think about them every time I look at myself now. To him I think that conversation is just over and done with, but for me it changed how I feel around him and how attractive I feel.
Then last night we had this stupid argument about the bathroom which I know sounds minor but it really wound me up.
He gets piss around the toilet all the time and then keeps asking why the bathroom smells. Last night he asked again and I snapped and basically said “because it smells like piss, because you keep pissing on the toilet.”
Then he asked me how he was supposed to clean it and I got even more annoyed because we’ve lived together for like 3/4 years and I’ve told him multiple times how to clean the bathroom. He’s also literally said before that I clean the bathroom better than him, like i was born with better bathroom cleaning skills that him, what?!.
I basically said if I didn’t exist he would somehow work out how to clean a toilet, so why is it suddenly my responsibility to know more about cleaning than he does, he cleans the kitchen fine so he’s got common sense?
He then said I was being a bitch because he’d “only asked two questions”, why it smelled and how to clean it, but from my point of view they weren’t just two random questions because we’ve had the exact same conversations multiple times already.
And I KNOW this isn’t because he’s straight. A bisexual guy can obviously also be messy, misogynistic, lazy, masculine, annoying etc. I’m not imagining bisexual men as some magical perfect species lol.
But I keep thinking about being with a guy who is bi and more feminine/androgynous and just more comfortable with that side of himself. Someone I could talk about men and women being hot with, someone who actually understands bisexuality without me having to explain it, someone who doesn’t seem so invested in being A Man all the time.
Basically I think I want a slightly twinky bisexual boyfriend lol.
Except there’s ANOTHER layer because sometimes I genuinely can’t tell if I want to be with that kind of guy or if I want to be that kind of guy.
From about 14-17 I had a really wobbly period where I desperately wanted to be a boy. That mostly went away, but I still sometimes look at feminine/androgynous men and get that “do I want him or do I want to look like him?” thing.
So now I’m just confused about all of it.
Do I specifically prefer feminine/queer men?
Would I genuinely feel more understood dating another bisexual person?
Am I projecting everything I dislike about my boyfriend onto “straight men” and imagining a bi boyfriend would fix it?
Is some of this actually about my own gender expression?
Or am I just falling out of love with my boyfriend and trying to explain it through sexuality?
The annoying thing is I don’t actually particularly want to leave him. He is a good person in a lot of ways. He’s kind, stable, dependable, we’ve been together a long time and built a life together.
But then I also keep thinking… is kind and stable enough if I’m not sexually attracted to him anymore and I’m increasingly getting annoyed/resentful about parts of who he is?
And I’m also terrified that I’m just being really picky. Like what if I leave a fundamentally decent boyfriend because I’m imagining this perfect queer guy and then end up with someone way worse?
Would really love to hear from bi women who’ve dated both straight and bisexual men, or anyone who’s had the whole “do I want them or do I want to be them?” confusion.
Did dating another bisexual person actually feel different for you? And does this sound like a sexuality/compatibility thing or does it sound like I’m just unhappy in my relationship?